In this article, we’re comparing two top-tier ice baths: the Desert Plunge and the Modtub 2.0. Both offer excellent performance, and you really can’t go wrong with either. That said, there are some key differences between them—and we’re here to break those down to help you choose the best fit for your needs.
 |  |
3,200 | $3,000 |
|
|
- Cools to 39°F
- Flow Rate: 1200 GPH
- Jed 303 Ozone Addon: $420
- 50 Micron Filters
- Exposed Plumbing
- Square Footprint
- 1 Year Warranty
- Cannot Remove Lid
- Cools to 39°F
- Flow Rate: 1,000 GPH
- Jed 303 Ozone Addon: $300
- 50 Micron Filters
- Vanity Cover
- Longer Footprint
- 1 Year Warranty
- Removable Lid
Form Factor: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
In this category, we’re comparing the Wide Grizzly 450 and the Modtub 2.0. As shown in the image below, the Modtub 2.0 is longer, while the Wide Grizzly 450 is wider. When it comes to cold plunging, we find that length often matters more than width. The Modtub 2.0 offers more room to extend your legs, reducing the need to bend your knees—something that’s especially noticeable in the more compact Desert Plunge. Aesthetically, we also prefer the longer, sleeker footprint of the Modtub 2.0 in a backyard setting, as it blends in more naturally than a wider tub.
Winner: Modtub 2.0
Chiller: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
Both the Modtub 2.0 and the Desert Plunge use an Active Aqua 1/4 HP Chiller. We’re big fans of this unit—it’s one of the best in its class. It’s durable, capable of reaching temperatures as low as 39°F, and built to withstand outdoor conditions year-round. The only negative is that with both of these companies, the chiller can only go on the right side of the tub.
Outcome: Tie
Lid: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
Overall, both lids are quite similar—they’re fully insulated, have a locking mechanism, and remain securely attached to the tub. However, there are a few key differences. The Desert Plunge lid includes a built-in latch that keeps it propped open during use, preventing it from accidentally closing on you mid-plunge. It’s a thoughtful safety feature, especially useful in windy conditions.
While the Modtub 2.0 doesn’t include a latching mechanism, it does allow you to fully remove the lid. We find this to be an excellent and even safer option—especially in harsh weather where there’s concern about the lid falling during a plunge. It’s also a convenient feature when hosting guests or managing multiple plungers.
Winner: Modtub 2.0
Color Options: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
Currently, the Modtub 2.0 is available in only two color options. While we do love our blue Modtub 2.0, we appreciate that the Desert Plunge offers a wider range of colors to match your space and style better.
Winner: Desert Plunge
Plumbing Configuration: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
The Modtub and Desert Plunge feature nearly identical plumbing configurations. While there are minor differences in their drainage setups, both are designed for efficiency, allowing water to travel the shortest possible distance.
Outcome: Tie
The Look: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
In our opinion, the Desert Plunge resembles a modified cooler that you can cold plunge in, whereas the Modtub 2.0 looks purpose-built for cold plunging. As shown in the image below, the Modtub 2.0 features integrated handles that contribute to its sleek design and compact footprint. In contrast, the Desert Plunge uses external handles that feel bulky and protrude from the body.
The Modtub 2.0 includes a sleek vanity cover that conceals and protects all plumbing and electrical components, giving it a clean, polished look—perfect for backyard setups. In contrast, the Desert Plunge uses an outdoor electrical box to shield its wiring from the elements, but the rest of the plumbing remains exposed.
Winner: Modtub 2.0
FAQ: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
What ozone does Desert Plunge use?
Both Desert Plunge and Modtub use a Jed 303 for ozone. At the time of this writing, Desert Plunge is selling theirs for over $100 more for the exact same product.
Overall Thoughts: Modtub vs Desert Plunge
Both the Modtub 2.0 and the Desert Plunge are solid choices for anyone looking to add a cold plunge to their wellness routine. The Desert Plunge stands out for its variety of color options and built-in safety latch, making it a practical option for casual users or those prioritizing simple functionality.
However, the Modtub 2.0 edges ahead in design and build quality. Its integrated handles, removable lid, sleek vanity cover, and longer interior make it feel like a premium product specifically engineered for cold plunging. It also blends more naturally into a backyard environment, offering both form and function.
At the end of the day, you can’t go wrong with either—but if you’re looking for a more refined, purpose-built experience, the Modtub 2.0 is hard to beat.
We believe the Modtub 2.0 offers the best value in cold plunges on the market. The tub features some of the best insulation we've seen, enabling exceptional efficiency in cold water technology!
Use code: plungereviews for $100 Off!
- World Class Insulation.
- Swivel open lid, with the option to be detached.
- 2 Drain Holes.
- Durable 1/4 HP Chiller.
- 50 Micron Filter.
- Cools to 39°F
- Limited Color Options.
- No Ozone (Comes as additional add-on).
- Approximately 75 gallons of water.
